MrBeast vs Caleb Hearon: Rolling Stone Ranking Sparks Heated Debate

Picture this. You wake up, grab your phone, and scroll through your feed. Suddenly, everyone is talking about a Rolling Stone list. Not about music. Not about rock legends. This one is about the 25 Most Influential Creators of 2025. And the surprise? Comedian Caleb Hearon landed at number six while the internet’s biggest giveaway king, MrBeast (Jimmy Donaldson), showed up at number seven. Yes, you read that right.

Wait, What Happened?

For years, MrBeast has been the guy who could drop a video, give away a car, plant a forest, or recreate an entire movie set and instantly pull in millions of views. So it seemed natural that he would be near the very top of the chart. Instead, Rolling Stone gave the spotlight to Caleb Hearon, a sharp comedian best known for his podcast So True. The announcement shocked fans and instantly created a buzz online.

MrBeast’s Tweet Heard Around the World

MrBeast did not take the news quietly. He went on X, formerly known as Twitter, and shared his frustration with a post that was quickly screenshotted and spread across the internet.

“According to this list a guy with 1 million followers is more influential than me. What did I do to piss off Rolling Stone?”

The reaction online was immediate. Many called it an ego slip. Others joked that Jimmy thought he was picking a fight with The Rolling Stones, the band. Memes poured in across timelines, poking fun at his response.

The Internet Claps Back

Other creators joined the conversation too. YouTuber Rosanna Pansino dropped a brutal line that caught everyone’s attention.

“MrBeast’s mask slipping this much in less than a year has been fascinating to watch. Caleb has something you’ll never have: A personality.”

Fans ran with it. Memes labeled him “Mr. Least” instead of “MrBeast” while many celebrated Hearon’s unexpected recognition as a win for comedy and authenticity.

The Backpedal

To be fair, MrBeast quickly tried to make things right. Within hours, he deleted his original post and shared something softer.

“Ngl after this I watched some of his stuff and it’s actually good. I deleted the tweet, I don’t want the smoke from the shooters, spare me plz.”

It was part apology and part damage control, but it showed how fast things can escalate online and how carefully big creators need to protect their image.

Who is Caleb Hearon?

For those unfamiliar, Caleb Hearon is not creating giant stunts or handing out millions. His influence comes from comedy and personality-driven content. Through his podcast and sharp humor, he connects with audiences in a way that feels personal and genuine. This moment introduced him to a much bigger stage.

So, What Does This Mean for Influence?

Here is the real question. What does it mean to be influential in 2025?

Numbers versus Nuance. MrBeast has the massive reach, but Hearon creates resonance that makes people feel something.
Scale versus Authenticity. Big productions bring in views, but authentic voices build stronger connections.
Cultural Impact. Influence is not just about being seen. It is about shaping conversations and sparking ideas.

The Bigger Picture

This entire situation was never only about rankings. It was about how we define influence today. MrBeast is still one of the most powerful digital creators in the world. But Hearon’s placement shows that sometimes influence comes less from the number of subscribers and more from the strength of personality and connection.

Image Credit: Steven Khan, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons